this is my go to eyeliner. it lasts along time. it can't be removed easily... 

I'm not a big fan of liquid eyeliner because I tend to be really picky but I have to say that for the price this is a great one. It does not smudge of move around thruout the day and yet its easy to wash off with a makeup remover. Great color ( got it in brown) and the applicator is perfect. Overall I would definitely recommend.