I've been using Etude House's eyebrow pencil for the last couple years, and as always, it works very well for me. It's super inexpensive, and matches my hair color really nicely! It's quite pigmented for me. I noticed that it gets a lot softer and darker when it's warmer (makes sense haha), and in the winter, it doesn't draw as darkly because of the cold. 

The colors are pretty similar online, so it makes it difficult to find the right color. I started off with No. 1 Black-brown. It matched my hair pretty well at the time, but when I got highlights and my hair started to lighten, it wasn't a good match anymore. I switched to No. 3 Brown, which was much better match for my hair, but not my eyebrows. I need to use a colored brow mascara to make it blend into my brow hairs better!

I absolutely love how inexpensive it is and it surprising lasts pretty long. I have used 1 in this color and 4 in total and currently have 2 back ups because I CANNOT leave the house without my eyebrows done and I would be devastated if I ran out without a replacement.